So many customers focus on picking the perfect golf simulator projector or the best launch monitor under $1000. While these things are important, the golf simulator enclosure and golf simulator screen you build your setup around are just as significant. 

We carry two of the most popular brands that make these types of equipment: Indoor Golf Shop vs Carl’s Place. You can’t go wrong building a simulator around either of these manufacturers, but which is right for you?

Indoor Golf Shop’s SIGPRO enclosure lineup comes in fixed sizes like the SIG8, SIG10, and SIG12, each with a finished black surround, padded tubing, and SIGPRO screens rated for 250-mph ball speed. The SIG10 fills a 10’1” x 7’7” image area, while the SIG12 steps up to an 11’5” x 8’7” screen for players who want a wider hitting zone.

On the other hand, Carl’s Place enclosure and impact screen models are more customizable. Their Premium and Preferred screens come in dozens of size combinations, including 16:9, 16:10, and large 10’ x 18’ formats, with Classic, flap, and loop-fastener edging. Their DIY and Pro enclosures give you more control over width, depth, and framing.

We’ll break down both options so you can build a setup that actually fits your room dimensions, the way you practice, and of course, your budget. Get in touch with our experts today for one-on-one support and bring your golf simulator to life.

What Does Carl’s Place Specialize in?

Carl’s Place is known for manufacturing some of the best impact screens and enclosures the industry has to offer. You get tons of control over screen size, edging style, and enclosure depth with this brand, so the setup fits the room instead of forcing the room to work around the setup.

Impact Screens

The Carl’s Place Premium Impact Screen is the one most golfers talk about. This three-layer, tight-weave polyester screen handles ball speeds up to 250 mph. 

It supports high-resolution projection and can be ordered in dozens of size combinations - 4:3, 16:9, 16:10, and 1:1 formats, with screen sizes ranging from roughly 7.7' x 7.7' all the way up to around 10' x 18' for large simulator rooms.

You also get to choose from an array of edging options: standard vinyl with grommets, vinyl with 7” safety flaps, or a loop-fastener border if you’re building a custom frame or adding blackout curtains.

They also sell a High-Contrast Gray Version of their Premium screen. Same three-layer construction, but the gray material cuts some brightness to help with washed-out images in rooms that have windows or overhead lighting.

Enclosures

Carl’s Place has four main categories on the enclosure side: 

• DIY Kits: Most budget-friendly. Uses steel corner fittings, black nylon enclosure walls, and whatever EMT pipe length you source locally. Popular sizes include 8' x 10.5', 8' x 12.5', and larger 16:9 layouts.
• Pro Enclosures: Upgrades the materials with a thicker nylon enclosure, a Premium screen by default, and selectable depths including 5', 8', 10', and 15'.
• Curved Enclosures: Great for golfers who want a more immersive experience, starting in the 4:3 and 16:9 sizes
• Built-In Room Kits: The cleanest option with no exposed piping, a wall-to-wall screen, and a cable/pulley mounting system for a more studio-type look. 

We’re proud to carry Carl’s Place enclosures and impact screens at the lowest prices online, backed by world-class customer service from A to Z. But is this the right fit for your simulator setup, or should you go with the SIGPRO series from The Indoor Golf Shop instead?

What Does The Indoor Golf Shop Specialize in?

The Indoor Golf Shop’s SIGPRO Gear is among the best the industry has to offer. These enclosures and impact screens are the core of what sets the brand apart.

Impact Screens

The SIGPRO Premium (white) and SIGPRO Premier (gray) are triple-layer polyester with a spacer mesh interior and a ball-speed rating of 250 mph. The white version is tuned to maximize image clarity; the gray version handles ambient light better by preventing hotspotting.

You can choose from 7’7” x 7’7” all the way up to 10’ x 17’6” for the Premier and 7’7” x 7’7” up to 10’ x 15’10” for the Premium. You can choose your aspect ratio as well. Replacement screens are cut specifically for SIG8, SIG10, and SIG12 frames with finished edges, Velcro attachment, and reinforced corners. 

Enclosures

Each SIG enclosure comes in a defined size with published frame and screen measurements, so you know exactly how it will fit before you buy. These are the three models most golfers compare:

• The SIG8 is their compact bay. The screen used in that enclosure measures roughly 8' x 8', with a finished black nylon surround and foam-wrapped tubing to handle mishits. It’s meant for rooms around 9' wide or slightly more.
• The SIG10 steps up to a larger frame: 10'10” wide, 8'4” tall, and 5' deep, paired with a 10'1” x 7'7” screen that fills edge-to-edge with the right projector. Perfect for most garage and basement builds with a predictable footprint and an image that fills the entire surface.
• The SIG12 is their flagship enclosure at 12'2” wide, 9'4” tall, and 5' deep, with an 11'5” x 8'7” screen. You get a wider hitting zone, and it’s great for playing with friends when you need more room inside the bay.

Every enclosure has a finished black surround, powder-coated tubing, foam padding on the pipes, and tensioning with 6” bungees that attach to reinforced grommets. No need to bother with cutting local EMT or mismatched screen sizes - consistency is the whole point of SIGPRO.

But if you don’t want to piece together a simulator, the brand also has its own simulator packages where the SIG enclosures are paired with launch monitors like the EYE XO, EYE XO2, SkyTrak+, or Mevo+. These bundles have projectors, turf, landing pads, and hitting mats.

Indoor Golf Shop vs Carl’s Place: Which Brand Should You Build Your Golf Simulator With?

Be clear, you can’t go wrong either way choosing between Indoor Golf Shop vs Carl’s Place enclosures, impact screens, and even hitting mats for that matter. These are two of the best brands you have access to. It comes down to the exact screen material, enclosure size, and build style that fits your room. 

We’ll help you weigh your options below. Just remember that a personalized recommendation is a few clicks or a call away at Indoor Golf Outlet, where you’ll get the best pricing and customer service for BOTH Carl’s Place AND Indoor Golf Shop!

Comparing Impact Screens

We’ve found that Carl’s Place impact screens are typically easier to match to a room with odd width, ceiling height, or a nonstandard frame layout. You gain access to a wider range of aspect ratios and dimensions, including 1:1, 4:3, 16:9, and 16:10. Their catalog spans dozens of exact cuts from 7.7' x 7.7' up to around 10' x 18'.

Each screen can be ordered with one of several edge styles: Classic vinyl/grommets, vinyl with extended safety flaps, or loop-fastener edges for custom-built frames. This level of customization is harder to achieve with The Indoor Golf Shop, unless you already have one of the brand’s enclosures.

Indoor Golf Shop sells screens that are cut to the exact dimensions of each SIG enclosure - SIG8, SIG10, and SIG12. A SIG10 replacement screen measures about 10'1” wide x 7'7” tall, and a SIG12 screen comes in at roughly 11'5” wide x 8'7” tall, each finished with reinforced edges, grommet rows, and Velcro strips sized to the frame.

Their screens arrive ready to drop into the enclosure without trimming or modifying anything, and tension is controlled with 6” bungees so the screen sits flat without bowing. The appeal here isn’t customization, it’s consistency. So which matters more to you? Choose accordingly. 

Comparing Enclosures

Similar to their impact screens, Indoor Golf Shop’s enclosure lineup is built around fixed frame sizes with published dimensions so it’s easy to piece together your setup:

• SIG8: 8'4” W x 8'4” H x 5' D frame with a 7'7” W x 7'7” H screen (1:1 layout)
• SIG10: 10'10” W x 8'4” H × 5' D frame with a 10'1” W x 7'7” H screen
• SIG12: 12'2” W x 9'4” H × 5' D frame with an 11'5” W x 8'7” H screen

Each enclosure includes the powder-coated pipes, black nylon surround, padding for the frame, and all the fittings. You don’t have to bother with cutting pipe or sourcing EMT to bring your setup to life. 

On the other hand, Carl’s Place gives you a lot more layout control:

• DIY Enclosure Kits include fittings, nylon, and screen - you just provide EMT 
• Pro Enclosures that ship with pre-cut netting panels and selectable depths like 5', 8', 10', or 15'
• Curved Enclosures designed for panoramic projection
• Built-In Room Kits for wall-to-wall installs with no exposed piping

The biggest difference between Indoor Golf Shop vs Carl’s Place is probably becoming pretty apparent. Carl’s Place lets you build around the room instead of changing the room to fit the enclosure. On the other hand, Indoor Golf Shop sells fixed, predefined sizes.

What Else Do They Offer?

Most customers come to us asking for help choosing between the enclosures and screens that Carl’s Place and Indoor Golf Shop make. But they make other components you’ll need to complete your setup - including hitting mats. 

Indoor Golf Shop makes some of the best golf hitting mats on the market. The SIGPRO hitting mats are available in a few different styles. The Softy mats are made from multi-layer foam (4’x7-4’x10’). The Softy Lite has a thinner profile and is great for putting on (4’x5’, 4'x7', 4'x10'). Indoor Golf Shop also sells golf simulator flooring cut to your exact layout. 

Carl’s Place sells its HotShot hitting mats, framing components, blackout curtains, ceiling baffles, and trim kits for finishing out DIY rooms. You can choose from a 4’x5, 4’x9’, or a 5’x8’ mat. The mats have a joint-friendly, premium fiber construct with 3 insert options.

Brand Support

You can rest assured you’re getting world-class customer service, whether you go with Indoor Golf Shop or Carl’s Place. That’s because you’re buying them from us here at Indoor Golf Outlet, and we stand behind everything we sell.

More importantly, though, you gain access to expert guidance every step of the way. If you need help interpreting dimensions, checking ceiling height, or matching a projector to screen size, we handle all of that.

Pricing

You can also narrow it down between Indoor Golf Shop vs Carl’s Place based on what fits your budget. Here’s a look at how the pricing shakes out across the products they offer:

Indoor Golf Shop runs higher on the enclosure side because you’re paying for pre-sized frames and finished kits. Carl’s Place starts cheaper but takes more measuring and hands-on assembly on your part, so that’s the trade-off you need to consider. 

Indoor Golf Outlet Stocks Both Brands at the Lowest Prices Online!

We hope this comparison of Indoor Golf Shop vs Carl’s Place has left you feeling clear on what each brings to the table and which is right for you. Both brands make strong impact screens and enclosures; it just depends on the space you’re building and how much customization you want.

Indoor Golf Outlet carries full product lines from both Indoor Golf Shop and Carl’s Place, which means you can compare screen materials, enclosure dimensions, and package options in one place instead of bouncing between stores.

We list every configuration at the lowest pricing allowed online, and our team actually helps you size these products correctly - including frame width, ceiling height, screen fit, projector throw, and hitting depth. 

Whether you want a SIG12 bay, a Carl’s Pro Enclosure with an 8' or 10' depth, or a custom-sized screen cut from Carl’s size grid, we’ll walk you through the exact pieces you need so buying doesn’t feel like a guessing game.

Reach out to our team anytime to get a tailored parts list and room-fit plan!